MUMBAI - "The war in Afghanistan is doomed to fail in the long run and the U.S. is not invincible," said Swedish Leftist intellectual and writer Jan Myrdal, during a lecture in India on Saturday.

RELATED NEWS:
Two Swedish officers killed in Afghanistan
‘See the world with Mao-glasses'

The son of Nobel laureates Gunnar and Alva Myrdal, the 83-year-old writer was in Mumbai to deliver the 2nd Anuradha Ghandy Memorial lecture titled 'Will the U.S. meet its Waterloo in Iraq and Afghanistan?'

"It is a war against people I know, love and respect. The anger is so strong I can taste the blood in my mouth when I see the images on the television," said Myrdal.

Acknowledging that India couldn't ignore the war because of its proximity to West Asia he said: "It is better for India not to get its fingers into this blaze."

Myrdal has lived in West Asia, China and India and has been a long-time critic of America's involvement in Afghanistan and Iraq. "The only good foreign soldier in Afghanistan is a dead one," he said.

Myrdal spoke of how imperialistic powers -- whether the U.S. now or England in the past -- prosper through divide and rule, leaving behind tragic consequences. "The U.S. is developing Shia-Sunni contradictions in Iraq to secure its own rule," he said.

Myrdal also pointed out that the U.S. was highly divided and Obama was being pulled in several directions, unlike Roosevelt who was a "stronger" leader.

"Things will get worse if one day the U.S. and its allies get involved in a war in Iran," said Myrdal. "Blair mentioned Iran 58 times in his speech last week. Another war is a looming threat."

Myrdal said common people have the power to change the course of history by opposing the war.

The lecture was made at St Xavier's College, near Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus, Mumbai (the capital of the Indian state of Maharashtra).

- -
To see more of the Hindustan Times or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.hindustantimes.com. Copyright (c) 2010, Hindustan Times, New Delhi. Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

Last Updated (Monday, 08 February 2010 20:42)

 

Comments 

 
#4 2010-02-11 04:37
This man is foolish communist who loves jihadists. Maybe this "Jan Myrdal" should travel to taleban areas with he's boyfriend and see what taleban thinks about gay marriage?

That would be fun thing to see.
Quote
 
 
#3 2010-02-11 04:35
Quoting DZ:
Myrdal is right! And the Afghan people has a right to defend themselves against foreign occupation, no matter what purpose the foreigners may give for there aggresion


Taleban movement was created in Pakistan. Afgan people? What about those afgans who are in ANA and Afgan police?

What about northern alliance? They were fighting againt Pakistani born taleban since early 90's. They are not afgans?
Quote
 
 
#2 2010-02-09 10:24
Well, Dave, you are certainly guaranteed to feel that way!
But, nevertheless, Myrdal is right! And the Afghan people has a right to defend themselves against foreign occupation, no matter what purpose the foreigners may give for there aggresion. This right is also well defined and guaranteed by the UN!

says
a Swedish citizen
Quote
 
 
#1 2010-02-08 15:49
If it is possible for immigrants to become Swedish after a few years in this country, it should of course be possible to claim that Myrdal is not Swedish anymore after so many years abroad. Thank god, for I would be ashamed of being Swedish where a man can claim that "the only good foreign soldier in Afghanistan is a dead one". I feel especially uneasy the day after 2 Swedish soldiers were killed in Afghanistan.
Quote